Robots given new assignments by Coach Keenan

I’m not a hockey coach, but I’m troubled by the Flames’ practice-time line combinations today as reported by the Herald’s Scott Cruickshank.


But? It should be noted that RW Eric Godard was off the ice with the regulars and Moss stayed out late (typically a sign of not playing).

So, let me get this straight:

  • For five of six periods, you play your best hockey of the last month, in competition with the hottest team in hockey.
  • Your forecheck is as active as it’s been all season, with David Moss leading the charge
  • You only score three goals in two games, but you also hit three posts and crossbars and have two sure goals stolen away when the opposing goaltender makes unbelievable and unlikely saves
  • You manage a split in San Jose that most said was not going to happen
  • Craig Conroy, working through an injury, is ineffective, even a liability, through those first two games
  • Alex Tanguay, working on your top line, is ineffective, even a liability, through those first two games

Therefor, Mike Keenan’s solution looks as though it’s going to be:

  • Keep Tanguay on the top line, and add Conroy to the mix
  • Scratch David Moss and break up this new energy line
  • Move Matthew Lombardi, your second most dangerous offensive player through two games, back onto a checking line

Sorry, don’t get it. Don’t get it either that Godard will again play, and again will not fight the man with two ladies’ name. Well, maybe I “get it” ā€” this is almost certainly a reaction to the three-goals-in-two-games issue … but splitting everyone up looking for better living through modern chemistry doesn’t seem to work for this team. Not to mention that, if that’s the goal, you maybe ought to think about reuniting Huselius-Langkow-Iginla, which was for a time the most successful grouping of the season for this team.

Now, Keenan has been more than willing to shake it up mid-game through the series so far, and if Nilson is back in that’s good news. But that doesn’t make up for Ball And Chain Godard’s presence on the bench, nor does it mean good things if you’re having to make mid-game adjustments because your game ain’t working.

One other thought before tonight: I was on YouTube the other day and spent a half-hour or so watching highlights from 2004. What struck me most about it was the sheer joy and passion the Flames showed playing the games ā€” guys like Shean Donovan and Ville Nieminen and Martin Gelinas were crazy out there, and it rubbed off on the whole team.

The lockout, the all-business tie, Nervous Jimmy, Andrei Zyuzin and Anders Eriksson later, and you have a group of robots who STARE DOWN THE GAME and often forget that you play better WITH emotion than without. I was heartened when I saw the fauxhawks, because it reminded me of the ’04 moustache-growing competition in its goofiness. Iggy even said: We’ve been too serious, we’re trying to loosen it up. In Game 1, it looked like that had happened: The hits, the blocked shots, the celebrations all said to me that the Flames wanted to be there. But after the penalty parade in Game 2, it was gone.

If they’re going to win, it has to come back.


~ by duncan on April 13, 2008.

8 Responses to “Robots given new assignments by Coach Keenan”

  1. Good stuff, can’t say I disagree with anything. I, too am surprised by the Conroy promotion, though part of me thinks it’ll last less than period.

    As for the Godard thing, Im starting to think it’s Keenan obstinately sticking to some old-school notion that a heavyweight is somehow required in the line-up, despite the player’s inability to actually play hockey.


  2. I think you’re right, but it goes past Keenan all the way to Sutter I think. As I was remembering ’04, it also struck me that Sutter often dressed Oliwa all the time through that run, regardless of opponent.

  3. Can someone tell me what Tanguay adds to this team? Bad turnover shorthanded leads to the first goal, then he takes YET ANOTHER offensive zone penalty.

  4. clearly kyle’s comment was written before tanguay’s brill pass to nolan for the GWG.

  5. I was thinking the same thing often through the game … and for all of Simpson’s criticism of Tanguay’s pass-first mentality, it DID lead to the game-winner in the end.

    This, too: Tanguay has been far more visible (and effective) than either Thornton or Michalek this series.

  6. I don’t really consider a player to have made a great contribution when they cost a goal and help set up one. He wouldn’t have needed to set up a great one if he didn’t make the initial bad play. And it’s not even like his penalty was useful in some way, it was just stupid.

    Stupid, stupid, stupid.

  7. I’m glad we won that game last night. Lucky that Sarich hit Marleau and caused the Sharks to draw a penalty. It’s a good thing Cujo filled in for Kippersoff.
    What’s this ugly rumour I hear about Iginla, Kippersoff and Huselius to be traded next year? My foreman Kent is telling me this is going to Happen.
    About last Thursday’s game. I have some respect for the Sharks and the people that live in San Jose but when I saw that scrawny runt of a teenage boy put up the “Loser” sign behind Iginla while he was in the penalty box. I’d sure like to see the little worm put in his place.Do you think he can score 50 goals in a season like Iginla? He couldn’t even make an Atom Division team.

  8. Allan, your foreman Kent needs to be demoted. Huselius has an expiring contract and hasn’t exactly been the apple of Keenan’s eye the past 30 or 40 games, so he’ll almost certainly be gone this summer. But Iginla and Kiprusoff aren’t going anywhere ā€” firstly because there’s no reason to deal them, secondly because I believe they both have no-trade contracts.

    As for the San Jose fans, I’ve never been there, but I’ve heard they’re very nice. And, as we learned in 2004, anchored by Neil Young!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: